Friday, 3 July 2009

July 2009 Club Email

Hi all,
Here's the Harcombe Diet Club news for July...

Thank you so much for signing up, buying books and for your queries – however you came to be on this email list. Please feel free to unsubscribe at any time if you don’t want any more updates.
I’ve just come back from a fascinating 3-day conference in Liverpool run by the “Association for the Study of Obesity.” Here are the things that I found most interesting:

Most amazing fact: A person with a BMI of 35 has 93 times the risk of developing Type II diabetes than a person with a BMI of 21. A BMI of 35 is also not breathtakingly high – 1.2 million people in the UK currently have a BMI of over 40. An average height woman (5’4”) who is 14 stone 7lbs has a BMI of 35 and an average man (5’9”) who weighs 17 stone has a BMI of 35.
Most interesting comment: One of the highlights of the conference was the opportunity to receive presentations from two obese people – sharing their experiences. One had had a gastric bypass and the other was waiting for one. The former said in his presentation “There are some people who are fat and happy, but I don’t know any”. My experience and findings would support this.

The big news in obesity is surgery. The Liverpool team is the most renowned and active in the UK and they are performing 1100 surgical weight loss operations a year. The NICE (National Institute for Clinical Excellence) guidelines say that people with a BMI of 40 or higher can be considered for weight loss surgery. That means 1.2m people ‘qualify’ already and that also means 10,000 people in the Liverpool area alone. 1,500 people are being referred to the Liverpool weight management centre each year, so this team simply cannot cope with demand, let alone clear any back log. If you have a bright child, wondering what career they should go into, weight loss surgery is the answer! Obesity is not generally a light-hearted topic, but there was one ‘fun’ moment when one of the speakers said about weight loss surgery “well, if you connect your oesophagus to your anus, of course you will lose weight.” This does quite nicely describe what the surgery options are, however, - bypass the digestive tract, shorten the digestive tract, and/or constrict the operation of the stomach in some way. We don’t know what this will do to vitamin and mineral absorption in the body, let alone the long term effects of surgery. Why would any government pay for operations like this before considering (in my view) less radical options such as banning transfats and sugar – the ingredients in the products that are the main cause of obesity?

The last ‘acceptable’ ‘ism’. There were some outstanding presentations on the psychological aspects of obesity and how ’fat’ people are seen and treated by society. The evidence that there is discrimination against overweight people is irrefutable and overwhelming. From childhood studies into weight and early school performance to discrimination in the workplace – evidence is widely available that overweight people don’t do as well at school and aren’t given the same opportunities at work. A Personnel Today journal (2007) survey of 300 senior managers and directors in business revealed that 79% of respondents considered it acceptable to discriminate (not hire/not promote) against overweight people. Their reasons? “These people are clearly weak-willed, lazy and out of control”. I see an overweight person and see (most likely) a calorie-counter and a victim of the wrong advice. The last thing I see that person as is weak-willed.
Childhood obesity: There was a jaw-dropping prediction from the childhood obesity expert at the conference – an adolescent who develops Type II diabetes is unlikely to see their 50th birthday! The psychological aspects of childhood obesity were also sobering. One brilliant study, done by Strauss & Pollack in 2003, involved 90,000 children across over 120 schools in the US. Children were asked to name their friends (they could name as many as they liked) and the results were then mapped onto a picture. This picture had a mass of white dots in the middle with high numbers of friend links going TO these white dots and a mass of black dots around the outside, with just one or two friend links for these people. The white dots were normal weight children and the black dots were overweight children. So much for fat and popular, let alone fat and jolly. This is cruel stuff. The final interesting comment in the area of childhood obesity was the view expressed that whether it is genetic or lifestyle (i.e. nature or nurture) “whenever I see an overweight child walk into my clinic I know that an overweight parent, or two, will follow.”

What I’m up to:
1) The biggest news by far for June was getting onto the Amazon best seller list. In the w/c 14 June 2009, “Stop Counting Calories & Start Losing Weight” spent 5 days in the Top 20 and the recipe book was in the Top 100. We were over the moon! A huge thank you to all of you who helped put it there. Books do drop off the list as quickly as they jump on, but we know that we’re knocking on that door and every article is a chance of getting back on the list.

2) Another wonderful highlight of the month was lunching with the producer of “Britain’s Biggest Loser” and the hunky trainer, Richard, from the programme! Fingers crossed to see if anything comes from this.

3) I did another ‘walk the pavements’ day with my wonderful publicist, EdenCancan, in London. We met Closer, Cosmopolitan, Glamour, Good Housekeeping, Psychologies and Red Magazines and an article for Glamour followed the same day. I’m in the October edition analysing the diets of a 4 women - size 8/10/12 and 14 – and 1 male. All with a view to see how they can eat more healthily, not just lose weight. It is really interesting to see what real people eat on a daily basis. Especially different sizes and genders.

4) I’ve had two features in “Heat” magazine in June. The second one was quite funny – it was an article on Kerry Katona having put on two stone since January and the dangers of yo-yo dieting. There was a cosmetic surgeon also quoted, talking about what liposuction actually is. The trouble is, the surgeon and I had our pictures and words mixed up, so my friends were texting me to ask “Since when do you know anything about liposuction – you faint at blood tests?!”

5) I’ll be sending you all the weekly diet tips that go to the media each week. The first one was on “How to lose or maintain weight on holiday”. There’ll be another one next weekend. I am doing youtube videos on most of these (www.youtube.com/zoeharcombe) if any of you prefer to view them, rather than read them.

Don’t forget - if any of you have any before and after pictures – we’re really happy to get you payments from magazines for them (the bigger the difference, the more they pay)! Our first case study Laura, is getting ready for a make over and photo shoot for “Closer”, any day now!
A request from my publisher and publicist – please can any of you who like the diet go on Amazon and leave a book review! I have thousands of email testimonials and about 8 reviews on Amazon! Thank you SO much.

We’re having a heat wave in the UK at the moment. If it’s hot where you are, cut back on carbs in the heat – it’s a great way to stay cool and lose weight at the same time. Carbs provide immediate energy and make you feel warmer. Salads, cold meats & fish will keep you cool and hunger-free.
All the best – ZoĆ« x

47 comments:

  1. Hi Zoe

    I bought your book after reading about it in Zest magazine and checking out your website. I have a BMI of 20 (through 17 years of calorie counting, I can tell you the calorific value of anything) so was not buying your book to lose weight. I was very interested in getting rid of my sugar cravings which have always been totally out of control. I have just completed phase 1 of your diet and it is amazing my cravings are under control and I have lost 2lbs even though I feel that I have eaten far more food than usual. I am so pleased that I bought this book that I have gone onto Amazon and left you a five star review and told everybody in my office about it. Also thank you for introducing me to puffed rice, I love it, I nibble on it when I need a snack. I am going to move onto phase 2 now but I am concerned about the muesli that I used to have, it is by Rude Health and is called the ultimate muesli with 23 ingredients. I have checked with the manufacturers and there is definately no added sugar in the product but it does contain lots of dried fruit which according to phase 2 is a processed food. I am worried that eating this muesli may affect my cravings again, what do you think? Also can I have soy sauce in phase 2 so long as it does not contain sugar or wheat?

    Thanks
    Naomi
    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Naomi, Thanks so much for your comment and I'm so pleased that we may be able to wean you off calorie counting!
    You've returned the favour on the brown rice cereal by introducing me to the Rude Health one. I've checked it out and I like the sugar-free and wheat-free a lot! You are right to be concerned about the dried fruit - and also the nuts (these have high carb and fat content naturally)
    With your BMI - the goal (as you so sensibly realise) is to keep cravings away and not to lose weight, so I would say - try it. Don't have too much the first morning and have it with (skimmed) milk to get some extra protein to keep hunger at bay and see how you go. If you find you are getting cravings again mid-late morning, you may decide it's not worth it. If you are still fine until lunch - good result!

    On the soy sauce - yes, this is fine in Phase 2 so long as no other processed stuff is added. If you were soy intolerant (this is much more common in the US) you would likely know by now, as you would have been craving the stuff quite specifically before Phase 1.
    Hope this helps and keep up the great work
    Very best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the advice Zoe, it is much appreciated...no more calorie counting for me, I am converted. Naomi
    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Zoe

    Like so many I too am an expert on calorie counting for many years and like so many I am still overweight. I received your book from Amazon last Wednesday 5th August, I read it through in 2 hours and I began in earnest on Thursday morning. You have completely overwhelmed me with your simplistic approach. IT ALL MAKES SO MUCH SENSE! I was afraid to weight myself at the beginning of the diet but medical intervention forced me to be weighed 3 days later on Sunday 9th Auust and the scales said 14st 4lbs. I weighed myself today, that's four days later and I weighed 13st 1lb!!! That's over a stone!! I am flabberghasted! I feel fantastic I love my food. I can't wait to wake up in the mornings to feel fantastic all over again. I am going to purchase your recipe book as soon as I have finished this comment. THANKYOU THANKYOU THANKYOU.

    (ps I take a blood thinner , warfarin, and the reason for the medical intervention was because my INR levels dropped dramatically. I believe this was because of all the 'greens' I have been eating over the last week. So perhaps you could warn others to be careful and get their inr checked as often as possible until they stabilise again. Once again THANKYOU from the bottom of my heart.

    Mrs Pat Murphy age 45
    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Pat - thank you SO much for sharing this. I think you've just taken the record for Phase 1! It stood at 14.5lbs and then Wendy on my facebook page (just last week) said she had lost 16lbs and this is 17!!

    Thank you SO much for your lovely comments as well - it still completely makes my day to see someone's life being changed like this.

    I've had a few emails recently from people who have seen their doctor and they've lost weight and other things have cleared up and one has my home page as his favourite and another asked the patient to borrow her book! There are so many brilliant doctors and nurses out there, desperately trying to help overweight people, and they see every day that eating less doesn't work. I would love them to realise that they can stop telling patients to restrict calories (which means they eat more calorie counted processed junk) and get them to eat better instead.

    Thanks again and keep up the great work
    Best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  6. Zoe PLEASE HELP! After the phenomenal success of Phase 1, I have PUT ON WEIGHT in Phase 2. I am at my wits end. I have put on 8lbs of the 15 that I lost. I have followed the plan religiously. I have followed the rules to the letter. I suffer greatly with hypoglycaemia but have managed to resist the temptation of bad carbs for the first time in my life. Has this happened to anyone else? I really feel distraught. I hope you reply to this soon.

    Regards

    Pat
    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Pat - I'm so sorry to hear this.

    After a lot of research, Phase 1 was scientifically designed to be the perfect diet to overcome Candida, Food Intolerance & Hypoglycaemia. The bottom line is, therefore, that if you move away from Phase 1 and the weight loss plateaus (I've never seen increases before) then this can only be because you have re-introduced something affecting 1 or more of the conditions.

    You should go back to Phase 1 and really look at the 3 conditions again and all the advice in the book about what to be careful about reintroducing and re-introduce things only when you know they are safe.

    It is getting increasingly common to be so carb sensitive that you won't be able to introduce many more carbs than are in Phase 1 without weight loss being affected. This need not be for ever, as your immune system will get stronger and enable you to tolerate more things.

    If you've gone back to fruit, as an example, that won't be good for Candida or Hypoglycaemia, as the book explains. Any wheat would be the chief suspect for food intolerance.

    Try another 5 days of phase 1 and then follow the advice for reintroducing foods 1 at a time and keeping a food diary. The safest food group to try should be dairy. If you don't have dairy intolerance, this will let you add milk and cheese to the things allowed in Phase 1 and this increases meal options a lot with very little carb added back in.

    It's difficult to go into much more detail on a blog - I do long or short phone consultations (details on theharcombediet.com) if this might help.

    Very best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Zoe

    Thank you so much for the immediate reply. I will follow your advice and let you know how I get on.

    Bye for now

    Pat
    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Zoe
    My first venture on here. Bought the 2 books from Amazon. Did phase 1 for 5 days then phase 2 for 2 days and weighed 12lbs less! Brilliant. Carried on with ph 2 for a week and only lost 2lb, very disappointed. Am now half way through 3rd wk. I don't cheat at all and only made one mistake by eating a peach without checking the book! I have over 7 stone to loose to get anywhere near a healthy weight for me. I have dieted all my life with little success. I am so worried that this wont work - not sure I could do phase 1 again very often. I worry about eating too many eggs because of the cholesterol, is this a real threat?
    Thanks for giving a glimmer of hope to this fatty! Kay
    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Kay - I am really sorry but there is not a person or formula on this planet that can predict weight loss. I don't mean that flippantly at all - it just can't be done.

    One of the many reasons that I started researching obesity is that the "to lose 1 lb of fat you need to create a deficit of 3500 calories" theory absolutely does not work. If it did, you having dieted all your life (as I did until I discovered all this) would have lost 7 stone 6lbs every year you stayed around 1000 cals a day. Most people who discover The Harcombe Diet are currently trying to live on 1000-1500 cals a day and not losing any weight at all - they should still be losing 3.10 - 7.6 stones a year! No formula works when it comes to the human body.

    At least you are now losing weight! You've lost a stone in 3 weeks, which is probably better than you've done for a while? And hopefully feeling healthier and there is no need to feel hungry again and you're not putting empty calories in your body any more. So hang on to all the positives...

    Phase 1 is the fastest weight loss programme I have come across (some people do better on this than Atkins, some the other way round - the 2 diets are very different in how they came about, but have similarly far better results than low fat/low cal diets).

    Weight loss will slow after the first week on any diet (two of the conditions, remember, cause serious water retention, so that bloating and puffiness will have gone substantially in the first week). It is quite possible that you have re-introduced some foods that are feeding the 3 conditions. I would re-read all the chapters on Candida, Food Intolerance and Hypoglycaemia and be really sure that you are 'ok' re-introducing anything that you have done. If you've gone back to wheat and/or fruit, for example, despite the cautions to watch these, that may well be causing problems (we're getting to the limit of what we can do on a blog - I get into this detail with clients)!

    Check all the things that have gone back in to your diet and follow the advice for testing foods one at a time to see what you really are safe with. Then, when you're sure what is OK, you've got a trade off decision to make - you can stay on Phase 1 for as long as you want and the weight loss should speed up. You are then trading off speed of weight loss vs enjoyment of eating - Phase 1 vs Phase 2. Phase 2 was designed to be a lifestyle plan where people could be healthy, eat lots of great food, carry on with life completely normally and still lose weight. If you find the Phase 1 weight loss quicker for you - that's the choice!

    On the cholesterol - I am researching this at the moment for another book I'm writing. There is pretty universal acceptance that eating cholesterol does not impact cholesterol levels. There are 2 schools of thought after this - those that think that saturated fat is the baddie and causes cholesterol and those that think we have been eating saturated fat for hundreds of thousands of years, so the idea of it being responsible for a modern disease is absurd.

    I am in the latter category - so is Gary Taubes if you want to read the brilliant "Diet Delusion". You can also go on youtube and put in "Cholesterol BMA Leeds" and watch some of the VT's by Dr Malcolm Kendrick. They are quite brilliant. You have to come to your own conclusion, but I don't worry for a nano second about any real food (saturated fat or not) that I put into my body. I wouldn't dream of putting the processed junk that is so widely available anywhere near me!

    I hope this helps a bit!
    Very best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  11. Thank you Zoe for taking so much time to answer me. It is very helpful and I will keep going. I am delighted that I haven't had any cakes,biscuits, choc or cheese since I started. I know that I can now eat cheese, but it is one of my weaknesses so I have decided to abstain for a while. Juat one question, if you don't mind, regarding the live yoghurt. Is the Easi Yo homemade yoghurt ok to use? It has all the good bacteria etc and is unsweetened. This diet is SO much more enjoyable than my last attempt (Lighterlife), so thank you. Kay
    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi there - I didn't realise you'd done lighter life. You're doing well to lose anything after that! You must have slowed your metabolism down to surviving on c. 500 cals a day. The more you give your body 3 good regular meals a day, the more it will stop storing fat and start working with you.

    Good call on the cheese - as soon as I hear 'weakness' I think craving and people need to stop eating what they crave. Ironically - at the point you could 'take or leave' something - that's when it's OK for you again!

    I'm sorry that I'm not familiar with the Easiyo yoghurt. I've had a quick surf to try to find the ingredients and I can't find them (the site is telling me what is not in the product - not what is). This makes me suspicious. What you need to see on the label is what is in there and it needs to say 100% yoghurt/milk cultures. The one I saw was fruit flavoured, which means something else must be in there. You're much better off with 100% bio/live yogurt - Tesco do a great own label version
    Keep up the good work!
    Best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi Zoe, it's me again. Your first failure! After our telephone conversation when you reiterated how important it is to stick with this diet (my resolve has never waivered), I am now in despair. Another week on Phase 2 and I have again gained weight (albeit 1lb). I don't know where I am going wrong. I am still abiding by the rules religiously. I honestly think I am eating too much and I'm ready to start actually counting the calories I am consuming within Phase 2. I have cried all monring. Never before has my determination been so strong but I am coming up against a brick wall. On the positve side my cravings have all subsided. My diet, which was mostly healthy could not be any healthier than it is now. I am a very rational, intelligent woman and understand completely how and why your diet should work. But it ain't working for me. I would be grateful for any further advice.

    Despairingly

    Pat Murphy
    ReplyDelete
  14. ps apologies for the spelling errors, I couldn't type this quickly enough!!!!
    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi Pat
    just wanted to encourage you to keep going. I don't know anything about your history, but I have had similar experiences of not loosing weight on diets and eventually it comes right! Drinking water has often been my downfall - just find it sooooo boring! I have many, many stones to loose, and it is coming off very very slowly with this diet, but at least it is a bit, and I have the consolation of knowing that its all good stuff that I am putting in to my body. I am thinking of going back to phase 1 for a few days to get another kick-start. Think I may have to do that quite often. Don't despair, I'm sure that Zoe will be able to help. Regards, Kay
    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Kay, thanks so much for your encouragement. I'm delighted to say that even though I haven't weighed myself in the last few days, I feel fantastic and clothes that were too tight are definitely getting looser. I am not going to weigh myself for a few weeks but just keep trying on my tight clothes to see the difference. I feel really healthy and I agree with you that if we stick at it our bodies will finally adjust and the weight will start to fall off. Thanks again for your encouragement and good luck on your journey also. Keep in touch.

    Pat
    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi Kay & Pat! Kay - Thanks so much for helping Pat, while I've been off line for a few days. A lovely woman called Melissa is helping everyone out on facebook/theharcombediet chat pages! Melissa could be an inspiration to you Pat - she did really well on Phase 1 and then slowed a bit and plateau'd in Phase 2 and stuck at it and is now over 2 stone down (in a couple of months I think - no more than) and she just keeps chipping away. It seems so unfair that a couple of the most 'hard working' dieters struggle even on this, but they are probably the ones who have most tried everything else and failed and the hope to find something that works is the greatest and the despair at set backs is also the greatest.

    If there is anything else that you think could work better you should do it (I know I would!) The trouble is I have all the research facts on the failure of any calorie counting option and 100 years worth of evidence that 98% fail! The only thing that I would recommend to people who didn't lose weight on The Harcombe Diet - would be the strictest phase of Atkins! It would be the absolute last resort (and even then Phase 1 of The Harcombe Diet has had more success for many people than Atkins). There is no point going low cal - always go low carb in preference, Hopefully you won't have to go this far (I would rather do Phase 1 than Atkins!) and the healthy eating will pay off soon.

    I really do wish I could predict how much people would lose and how quickly but there absolutely is no formula. I really hope you get your deserved success soon.
    Very best wishes to you both - Zoe x
    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello Zoe,

    Not sure whether my earlier comment ever reached you - so I'll try again as I'd really like your advice ! I have jsut completed phase 1, I only had the She article to go on and I did fail a bit - I had milk in tea and scrambled eggs. Is semi skimmed milk really no good ?

    I did lose weight but not a significant amount, so am back on Phase 1 again today.

    My biggest issue is that I have such trouble sleeping now - it's been really bad. I try to have the carb meal at night to help but on the She article I think that was only once - and I didn't know what the other options were. When it was a fat meal, I really couldn't sleep much at all.

    So I'd really like to know whether I really have to cut out all milk for 5 days, whether it makes a difference ?

    I did cheat and has some of Willie's chocolate (do you know it ?) when the cravings were horrific, but now I really don't have cravings so am hoping that Phase 1 will be easier to repeat.

    I'm just disappointed with the lack of 'significant' weight loss, which would really have spurred me on, as the diet suggested would happen. I don't have scales - I think of them the same way that you think of counting calories - I know if I'm feeling and looking my normal weight without them.

    Could it be that a bit of Willie's chocolate and the milk has really stopped me losing significant weight because that's all I've cheated with.

    Would really apprecaite your advice - otherwise I'm not finding it too hard to carry on though I am bored stiff with all the cooking, prep, vegetables, and I'm sure I smell like a boiled veg !
    ReplyDelete
  19. Hi there - it sounds like you could do with both books! The diet book and the recipe book. I can't repeat the 400 pages of advice already written here! (and that's just the diet book)
    Best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  20. thanks Zoe - I have just bought the recipe book wich arrived today.

    I did wonder about the milk advice though - in Phase 1 is it going to make a masive difference to weight loss if I have semi skimmed in tea ?

    My Chiropractor advises Quinoa for breakfast - something I see you haven't mentioned at all. What do you think ?

    And the poor sleeping ? What is that down to and will it improve ?

    Thanks !
    ReplyDelete
  21. Hi there - the milk will only make a difference if you have dairy/lactose food intolerance - the book can help you decide if this applies.

    Quinoa is on p129/132/143/144/305 of the diet book and p6/8/16/96/158/174/198/213/366 and 388 of the recipe book.

    The sleeping I've not come across before. There is no reason why eating real/good food should do anything other than help you sleep better! It may take a while for this to happen - depending on what your diet was like before, you could have been having low blood sugar/carb 'drug' induced sleep, which may not have left you feeling very refreshed.
    Best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  22. Hi Zoe. Thanks for your positive comments. I just want you to know that I do not intend to try anything other than the Harcombe. I believe in my heart that it is the correct lifestyle change for me and taht it will indeed eventually pay off! I think that, odd as it may seem, I am at my 'plateau',despite having just started. But greater things will happen, of that I am confident and I cannot 'weight' to let you know some day that I have achieved my natural weight. I won't torture you too much from now on but will look in on the blog from time to time to see if I can be of help to anyone else and to catch up with Kay and others who are true believers! Bye for now.

    Pat x
    ReplyDelete
  23. thanks Zoe. I should have added "in Phase 1" to my comments above. I can see that Quinoa is ok in later Phases but I didn't want to comfuse myself by reading too far ahead.

    Now that I have graduated from two rounds of Phase 1, I have started reading Phase 2. It will be interesting to see what happens as I expand my food range.

    One thing that puzzles me is that I can no longer eat my favourite lunch of backed potato and tuna (tinned, in spring water), because of the no fats with carbs rule. I understand your logic here completely. But, I always thought that tuna (and other fish and meats) were protein and not fat ? So I am really confused now ! Please could you elaborate ? I've been through all the meal plans and it seems low fat cottage cheese it about it with a baked potato. I guess baked beans are out because of the high sugar and processed nature of the product.

    Am I wrong in thinking all these years that mean and fish are protein ?
    thank you.
    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi there - protein is in everything so the full hand words in the book should be carb/protein and fat/protein throughout, but we just drop the word protein. There is protein in lettuce, fruit, bread - every real food (none in sugar - wonder why?!) So tuna is fat/protein and - depending on which variety of tuna you have - it can be 31% fat and 69% protein (always 0% carb).
    (P131 of SCC does talk a bit about the spectrum of carbs and fats). Tuna and baked potato is better than lamb and baked potato on this spectrum, but both are mixing. Better options are the LF cottage cheese, as you say, and also veggie chilli, veggie curry, ratatouille - any carb options that go with spuds.
    Hope this helps
    Best wishes - zoe
    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi Zoe & Pat
    I am plodding on and loosing about 3lb a week. I thought it would be more, considering the huge change to my diet, but am content to keep going. I struggle a bit without gravy and sauces, but otherwise am doing ok. I don't have many carb meals (is that ok Zoe), just shredded wheat for breakfast. I eat mostly chicken, fish or eggs, with salad or veg and berries and bio yog for my puds or treats! Now then, I am a complete blockhead when it comes to computing - how do i get on facebook, without telling the world and his mother all about me? I know, I'm off the ark, haven't even mastered digital cameras yet! Hope you are doing ok Pat. Regards, Kay
    ReplyDelete
  26. Hi Kay, Well done on your 3lbs a week, that's bloody good! I haven't weighed myself yet but as long as I am feeling so good the weight doens't seem to matter as much. I do feel my rings looser and can pull my belt in a little tighter. My hair is shining and I have a lot more energy. Like you, I stick more to the fats than the carbs and my cravings and hypoglycaemia have gone completely. I am very partial to the tomato sauce recipe in the book which I have almost every day with chicken or fish. I miss my NLY but it definitely triggers a bad reaction with my vocal chords, and being a singer I can't afford to indulge. I'm off to Spain for a few days and am looking foward to indulging in the wonderful Mediterranean cuisine, mindful of the "rules". Speak to you soon and keep up the good work. (ps I tried Facebook for 5 seconds and felt very vulnerable as I got all these emails from people who said they were "friends". So I cancelled it immediately! If you find a solution, let me know. Adios for now.

    Pat x
    ReplyDelete
  27. Hi Zoe -

    Just completed Phase 1, and delighted to find 9lbs have gone. A quick question - is diet Indian Tonic Water ok? I read that decaf Diet Coke is fine and wondered if that applied to all decaf diet drinks? The diet is great - not hungry, full of energy, better eyesight - fabulous!

    best wishes

    Kate
    ReplyDelete
  28. Hi Kate! Many thanks for your lovely comments and I'm so pleased this is helping you lose weight and gain health - that is the idea!

    On the diet coke - p168 in the green book refers to cola and p272&273 refer to diet coke. None of them talk about it as being "fine"! The furthest I think I go is that they should be seen as 'cheats' even before Phase 3, but, if you must have diet coke, then decaf is better than caff and cola is better than fruit fizzy drinks!

    Check out the question on sweeteners on the questions link on the home page (http://www.theharcombediet.com/content/questions-answered/index.asp), The most FAQ is on sweeteners and there is a full answer here. Even since writing SCC I have found evidence that sweeteners impact insulin. This was confirmed in the press last week!

    Keep up the great work - Zoe x
    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks Zoe - back to regular water then!
    ReplyDelete
  30. Hi...I love the sound of the Harcombe Diet, but having bought whole libraries of diet books I am wondering a couple of things:

    1. How are women in their 40s going with weight loss doing the HD?

    2. Can the guidelines be easily adapted for people with food allergies and intolerences (eg, dairy, soy, wheat, eggs)?

    3. Are the guidelines specific - are there sample menus, rather than complicated instructions like 'eat carbs 5 minutes before protein, but 3 minutes after fats....' (I am old and easily confused!)

    I want to believe, but don't want to get my hopes raised...as too often I think I have found THE solution only to find that 'solutions' is a dubious or extreme pile of bunkem!

    Thanks!
    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi there - I could just say buy it and I will give you your £7.99 back if you think it's the same as all the others! I'll try and explain more ...

    99% of diets are based on getting you to eat less and/or do more. The other 1% are Atkins etc. The 1% will work (but you may not like the food options); the 99% will NOT work and we have known this as far back as 1945 - we just pretend that if we keep doing the same thing, we will get a different result - this is literally a defintition of madness!

    The Harcombe Diet explains why the 99% don't work and explains why they will in fact turn you into a hungry food addict. It then uses everything I've learned in many years of research to come up with something that will work.

    I smiled when I saw your note on food intolerances - this is one of the founding principles of the book! Not only does the diet work for people with these, it assumes that most people have them because they are caused by dieting!

    As for 40 year olds - my 1-1 clients are anything from teenagers to 70+ and they'll doing great. I get email testimonials every day - I just don't know how old the people are!

    The guidelines are very simple - again - the book explains that 1/2 grapefruit and then 2 teaspoons of something else 5 mins later is mad. This will just tell you what you can eat and what you can't and what you eat with what!

    Hope this helps any other 'tried everythings' also - I was one of those by the way and still have a shelf full of diet books to prove it. They make me laugh now!
    Zoe x
    ReplyDelete
  32. p.s. sorry about the they're typo - rushing off to London!
    ReplyDelete
  33. Thanks Zoe for your considered and personalized response...that has been enough for me to order THD online....after I receive that I will take a look and see about ordering the recipe book too. Glad to see there is a recipe book - too many diet books have guidelines such as "lunch = salad" that could be something without enough nourishment like two leaves of lettuce, or a full wardorf salad with waaay too much fat!

    Yes, I had noted that there was a food intolerence basis to your diet...which is great! However, having been slow to realise the extent of my food intolerences (it has taken an environmental physician some time to work through much testing) I have eliminated many of the problem foods and have far less symptoms - but sadly still far too much weight. Various food intolerence books I have read so far advocate fasting and other methods that have failed for me before (okay, I have managed to fast but went back to foods with an even stronger appetite!) and some very compicated elimination and roation diets. I have also tried adapting the likes of Weight Watchers to a wheatfree, dairyfree etc version only to find I am not sure if I have balanced my food groups well enough to maintain good health...

    I am 45 and my weight gain occurred at the age of 28 (coinciding with the onset of hypo thyroidism and subsequent partial thyroid removal) in a short time my weight doubled. I am now about 15kgs below my top weight, but it does not move easily. I do exercise regularly - a regime supervised by a physiotherapist. Due to lifestyle changes (cutting out junk food etc sometime ago) I am no longer gaining weight...however, I don't lose any either!

    To say I am past desperate to lose weight is an understatement. I will follow your plan with an open mind and let you know how I get on. Apologies for sounding suspicious of your work, that is more about me feeling resigned to a fat and unhealthy old age. I am quite happy to be your pinup girl for over 40 success should this work for me...I will provide photos and all! LOL! Kind regards!
    ReplyDelete
  34. Dear Life slurper

    I just had to comment on your comments! I haven't laughed so much in ages at your witticism. I wanted to let you know that I too am a 45 year old who is finding it extremely hard to lose weight. The Harcombe Diet has been instrumental in making me aware of what foods trigger my cravings at certain times and being menopausal you can imagine that hormones do make one crave rubbishy foods. I have not been as successful as others who are following Zoe's advice but I feel bloody brilliant. My weight loss is slow ie 1lb week average but it is a damn sight better than previous attempts at counting calories. It used to be very easy for me to shed pounds but since turning 40 it has not been quite so. I wish you luck. This diet is for real, I cannot emphasise enough how good you will feel once you get over Phase 1. The Recipe Book is also brilliant and I have had some fantastic family meals/parties based on them. I look forward to hearing how you get on.

    Pat
    ReplyDelete
  35. Hi Pat - thanks so much for your lovely comments! I'm also 40 something, so we're all in the same club!
    Bye for now - Zoe x
    ReplyDelete
  36. Hi Pat!

    Witticism...or did you mean weighticism??

    That is fantastic to hear of your success! A average of one pound per week loss would be brilliant...even half that...anything to see the scales on a downward trend as a result of healthy eating vs starvation, fasting, or processed/packaged meal replacements.

    There are lots of success stories for THD posted around the Web (they are all over the place) and I am working my way through them...I hope to find some from those who have had huge results over time, beyond the first phase - I am one bigger gal who needs hope!

    The book doesn't seem to have been released here in Australia yet...grrr...my express overseas order is yet to arrive....argghhh!!!

    Thanks!
    ReplyDelete
  37. Hi Zoe and Lifeslurper,

    I have just been given a copy of SHE magazine with the Harcombe Diet featured and am getting very excited.

    Last year, I turned forty and for some reason the weight piled on and it became impossible to shift, despite trying so many different things. Today is the first day of phase one and so I will let you know how it goes.

    Zoe, I love the theory of the diet and not being restricted to amounts - I loooooove food and so dieting is always a huge mountain. This diet seems more a way of life that can be easily adopted. Thank you!

    Just one question: Can I drink a glass of freshly pressed carrot juice in phase 1? I am having desperate sugar cravings and this is the only way I can think of having something sweet and it not be sugar!
    ReplyDelete
  38. Hi Emma:

    Is is exciting isn't it? And for so many reasons!

    I for one am so glad to see the old calorie counting given the boot...gee whiz! Counting every last calorie doesn't stop any one from living on sweets and potato chips - oh sure, you wouldn't eat much volume because of the high caloric content but how healthy would you be?

    For ages now, I have been monitoring my own calorie intake by using one of those online food databases while I try to repair my Candida and food intolerance innards only to find my average daily intake is certainly under 2000 cals - and usually closer to 1500....yet I maintain all of this extra blob! Add daily exercise - and you guessed it - no change on the scales....sure I feel better for the exercise but the scales really need to start on a downward trend. I know that in the past I have abused my poor old system in my attempts to lose weight and have now probably made it very hard to shift weight, but I can't tell you how excited I am to now be trying THD filled with good old fashioned healthy food and a focus on controlling various condtions while losing weight!

    Emma, as a fellow 40+ I will be keen to watch your progress..best wishes!

    LS x
    ReplyDelete
  39. You echo much of what I have done, and for the last few weeks prior to finding the THD I too was dieting via an online calorie counting site - it was great and gave you a break down of what you ate and encouraged you to eat healthily. But what happens if I am allowed around 1500 calories, I will happily survive on cinnamon bagels with peanut butter or chocolate.

    I wonder why I didn't lose weight???

    I am trying not to weigh myself everyday but couldn't help it this morning - I lost 2 pounds. So far so good. Today the headache has kicked in to thank god it is the weekend and I can sleep through most of it.

    Here's to blobbiness being in the past!
    ReplyDelete
  40. Emma:

    LOL to living on cinnamon bagels, peanut butter and chocolate!

    Well my book arrived today - a little earlier than its revised delayed expected arrival - so I am delighted and easing myself into it today..no more of this 'tomorrow' stuff.

    Might have a few challenges ahead sourcing some things...I won't be having aggs - but had hoped various egg 'replacement' products wouldn't be filled with the kind of stuff they are...but now having the book can see that it is possible to have a bacon only breakfast in Phase I if need be. Then the bacon - who would have thought something that looks like fresh meat is 20% 'other' stuff....did not have THD notes to hand at the supermarket so didn't feel confident to buy bacon. I raced to the shops too excited...so now I will make a better plan and try to source some goods like goat's yoghurt and creamed coconut, and more 'bacony' bacon from other places. Anyways, the eating looks great...so I had better be able to find the food!

    Good riddance to 'el blobbo!'

    LS x
    ReplyDelete
  41. Great to hear your book has arrived. I am still waiting for mine as I live in the Middle East and I can't get hold of a copy here. So I am doing phase one from what I can find on the Internet.

    I am very interested to see how it goes for you LS.

    I have lived through 2 days of extreme headaches and today they are abating slowly. I am just hoping that the sugar cravings disappear and I can live without the cinnamon and peanut butte bagels - they really are a killer.

    Good luck with the bacon hunt - in terms of pork I take what ever I can find!!!.

    Still curious to know if freshly squeezed carrot juice is allowed? I figure that if you can eat carrots as a snack, then the juice should be OK. RIght? Or is this just my sugar craving saboteur talking to me........

    Waiting to hear how you get on LS!
    ReplyDelete
  42. Emma:

    Oh you poor thing...waiting on the book!!!! I know that feeling.

    Remembering I am not Zoe - nor am I qualified to speak on THD, but have just had a quick look for you and I believe the answer is *NO* to carrot juice....while it is freshly squeezed (as opposed to packaged) you are altering the original state of the carrot by removing the fibre etc...short version is that you risk feeding your cravings!

    I'll do you a deal: keep away from the carrot juice and I will start my withdrawal from cups of tea (with milk) *sob*!

    I hope someone will correct what I have written - I wanted to try and answer Emma....waiting to get a copy of THD can be tough whne you just know it is going to do wonderful things for you!!!!

    LS x
    ReplyDelete
  43. Hi both! - I can't keep up with all the blogs and sites everywhere! Many thanks for helping each other out while I try and finish the next book also!
    Carrot juice is not a good idea - LS is bang on and has the right explanation! If you eat all the pulp from the juicing machine, you are then effectively eating the whole carrot so eat the carrot. There is a reason why you can't eat 20 carrots but you could eat the juice of 20 carrots and the body will release the wrong amount of insulin and you will then be craving anything to get your blood sugar raised!
    Best wishes - Zoe x
    ReplyDelete
  44. Thank you both for your help!

    Sob to the carrot juice!

    The good news is the headache has gone. Even better news is that I will be flying to the UK next week and so can pick up a copy of the book then! Yeah!!!!

    Being an "afternoon tea girl" I sympathise with you on the milk in tea! I find it hard to live with out milk AND sugar in my tea, so have given up tea altogether for the herbal ones. I am not sure life will ever be the same again!

    How about rice milk? Or is that cheating???

    Feeling slimmer and so that keeps me going. Desperately trying not to jump on the scales every five minutes and counting down until Thursday morning, when the big revelation will happen when I do jump on the scales!

    Zoe this is a fabulous diet, and as you can probably tell, I am looking forward to figuring our all the ways I can cheat on phase 2 and still lose weight.

    When are you starting phase 1 LS?

    Let the battle of the blobbiness begin. . . .

    xx
    ReplyDelete
  45. I am 50+ (55 to be precise). I've done every diet imaginable and always ended up putting on more weight than when I started. I'm absolutely delighted with the diet - I lost 7lbs in phase 1 and have so far lost 1st altogether. My weight has stayed put for the past month but only because I've had several parties, barbecues etc and a holiday. I need to lose another 2 stone, so am back on track now, but at least I know now what I have to do to maintain my weight and not let it creep up again when I do reach my ideal weight.

    My taste buds have changed and I've noticed that a lot of stuff I used to eat is now way too sweet (I never thought I'd hear myself say that). Wheat was always a problem for me, but now I find I can eat it occasionally with no bad effects.

    I love this diet!
    ReplyDelete
  46. Hi Reet - thanks so much for your lovely comments. I'm so pleased to hear that this is helping you. Keep up the great work!
    Very best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete
  47. HI EVERYONE - just to let you know this blog has now moved to our main www.theharcombediet.com web site. On the home page, you will see "BLOGS" - so we have them all in one handy place now. I could never find them!
    Look forward to seeing you over there
    Best wishes - Zoe
    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.